Custer County, CO: Foreclosures, Tax Liens & Distressed Properties

Custer County, CO, Colorado: 4 ZIP codes scored, Custer County, CO averaging 17/100 (low, Custer, CO), from 15 to 20. Custer County, CO is in its peak phase (Custer, CO confidence 18/100): Custer, CO home prices up 2.2% (Custer, CO) over twelve months. Custer County, CO lender headwind: 63/100.

Highest-scoring Custer County, CO ZIPs: 81069 (20/100), 81253 (17/100), 81226 (15/100), 81252 (15/100).

Across Custer County, CO's scored ZIPs: median home value $327,600, household income $67,988, 22.1% vacancy, 12.9% poverty, 84% owner-occupied, median age 54.1.

Custer County, CO insurance distress 40/100 (#1,297 in the US); FEMA hazard 78/100 for Custer, CO; 6 federal disaster declarations in Custer County, CO since 2023; Custer, CO construction distress 69/100.

2 banks with 2 branches lend in Custer County, CO; Custer, CO weighted bank stress 69/100, highest 79/100 in Custer, CO.

Custer County, CO unemployment 4.5%; 74 new housing units permitted in Custer County, CO over twelve months, Custer, CO down 20% from 92; Custer, CO home prices +14.2% a year (Custer, CO) over three years.

4,631 housing units in Custer County, CO; 351 Custer, CO renter households; 33% of Custer, CO renters spend 30%+ of income on rent, 21% (Custer, CO) half or more.

Custer County, CO ranks #344 nationally on the opportunity index (Custer, CO, among all ranked counties); Custer, CO scores 34.4/100 and Custer, CO sits #1 inside Colorado. Custer, CO is in the peak_opportunity opportunity phase; Custer, CO's primary driver is vacancy, Custer, CO second driver construction; Custer, CO moved down 30 places. 5 short-sale listings across Custer, CO; 94 days on market observed in Custer, CO; 36.0% vacancy over 4 Custer, CO ZIPs.

No CFPB county sample covers Custer County, CO. The non-metro area reading for Custer, CO: 0.8% ninety-plus days late; Custer, CO's thirty-to-eighty-nine share is 1.5% (Custer, CO, December 2025 data); Colorado overall 0.7%.

Custer County, CO has 1 watched bank; 1 Custer, CO bank sits in an elevated band. Custer, CO footprints: Stockmens Bank (1 branch, stress 59) in Custer, CO.

1,959 of the 4,631 housing units in Custer, CO sit vacant. Custer County, CO permitted 0 multifamily units in twelve months; Custer, CO's one-to-four unit structures added 74 units in Custer County, CO.